| 2020 | Not Awarded |
| 2019 | Marc McGeehan |
| 2018 | Al Turdo |
| 2017 | Hank McClary - Softball |
| 2016 | Dave Race |
| 2015 | John Santo, Assignor - Soccer |
| 2014 | Robert Varju - Football/Baseball |
| 2013 | Jack Baum, Assignor - Basketball; Official - Baseball/Basketball/Softball |
| 2012 | John Becker - Basketball/Football |
| 2011 | Sam LaValva - Basketball/Baseball/Softball |
| 2010 | Bob Bachman - Phillipsburg |
| 2009 | Joe Galayda |
| 2008 | Ruth Gibbs - Field Hockey |
| 2007 | Kenda Riley - Softball/Field Hockey |
| 2006 | Howard Norgalis - Swimming |
| 2005 | Dave DeYong - Basketball |
| 2004 | Joe Shaw - Football/Baseball/Softball |
| 2003 | No Award Given |
| 2002 | No Award Given |
| 2001 | Barbara Hudock - Field Hockey |
